While rooted in the admirable pursuit of emotional intelligence and secure attachment, extreme interpretations of gentle parenting have drifted away from balanced child development.
Children need empathy, but they also need boundaries and the chance to experience frustration with support. I love this reminder that being a loving parent doesn’t mean avoiding every difficult feeling. How do we help parents find that balance without feeling guilty for saying no?
Thanks for the positive comments and your reminder that kids need boundaries and the chance to experience frustration with love and support. Guilt is never far away from everything parents do. It can be caused by going against current norms or methods other parents use; as a result of what kids do or say; or going against how we were raised. It seems also that mothers feel way more parental guilt than fathers too. I suspect that has something to do with the innate nurturance of mothers as opposed to dads who always want their kids to be better so they push, teach and can be critical. Also parents of large families tend to experience less guilt than parents of small families, even though they have more skin in the game. Tip for reducing guilt: Raise your small family with a big family mindset. Note, this is made by a male!!!🤔😉😂
Well said. By the way, I'm Ruth, I write R.B.'s Substack, personal essays on identity, family, and the things we don't say out loud. If that's your kind of reading, feel free to check it out, and always open to collabs too.
As a grandparent whose grandchildren are being gently parented I so appreciate this! I witness endless negotiations & "I know you want dessert & you're sad that you won't get it but you didn't eat your dinner."
Then the relentless begging, pleading & arguing begin. The parents finally relent & say OK, the kids get dessert & the parents marvel at what persuasive salesmen the kids will grow up to be. My son says it's "easier" to give in.
Little to no discipline is meted out & the childrens' behavior shows it. It makes me crazy! My son knows better because he was not raised that way. I wish I could share this piece with him but he would be offended & annoyed.
Love your perspective Virginia. As an experienced parent you can see the traps quite obviously for parents who follow wholeheartedly gentle parenting. While we’ve beyond ‘because I said so’ as a method that doesn’t mean everything is a negotiation. It’s tiring! Share the piece with your son- just frame it in a way that he won’t take offence.👍
Children need empathy, but they also need boundaries and the chance to experience frustration with support. I love this reminder that being a loving parent doesn’t mean avoiding every difficult feeling. How do we help parents find that balance without feeling guilty for saying no?
Thanks for the positive comments and your reminder that kids need boundaries and the chance to experience frustration with love and support. Guilt is never far away from everything parents do. It can be caused by going against current norms or methods other parents use; as a result of what kids do or say; or going against how we were raised. It seems also that mothers feel way more parental guilt than fathers too. I suspect that has something to do with the innate nurturance of mothers as opposed to dads who always want their kids to be better so they push, teach and can be critical. Also parents of large families tend to experience less guilt than parents of small families, even though they have more skin in the game. Tip for reducing guilt: Raise your small family with a big family mindset. Note, this is made by a male!!!🤔😉😂
Well said. By the way, I'm Ruth, I write R.B.'s Substack, personal essays on identity, family, and the things we don't say out loud. If that's your kind of reading, feel free to check it out, and always open to collabs too.
As a grandparent whose grandchildren are being gently parented I so appreciate this! I witness endless negotiations & "I know you want dessert & you're sad that you won't get it but you didn't eat your dinner."
Then the relentless begging, pleading & arguing begin. The parents finally relent & say OK, the kids get dessert & the parents marvel at what persuasive salesmen the kids will grow up to be. My son says it's "easier" to give in.
Little to no discipline is meted out & the childrens' behavior shows it. It makes me crazy! My son knows better because he was not raised that way. I wish I could share this piece with him but he would be offended & annoyed.
Love your perspective Virginia. As an experienced parent you can see the traps quite obviously for parents who follow wholeheartedly gentle parenting. While we’ve beyond ‘because I said so’ as a method that doesn’t mean everything is a negotiation. It’s tiring! Share the piece with your son- just frame it in a way that he won’t take offence.👍